Warning: is_writable() [function.is-writable]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/php-tmp/upload) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 348

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361
celkem odměn uk kasino kostky kostky na prodej na prodej Katalánsko Bavaro Beach Golf & Casino Resort Higuey Dominikánská republika drueckglueck kasino 20 otočení zdarma mobilní sázka 365 ee turnajové pokerové kasino nord pas de calais software pro správu pokerových stolů zynga black diamond casino otočení zdarma restaurace ředkvičky klaipeda jak hrát betway kasinové hry aplikace kasino život rdr2 okrást hráče pokeru legrační online pokerová jména rychlé výplaty online kasina herní automaty online zdarma live kasino hotel od nuly po hrdinu cityman kasino kasino orient express bez bonusu mirage hotelové kasinové restaurace v pokeru to, co je královský flush nové kasino chisinau význam kamenné bubliny dračí úkol xi kasino trik Sada pro 8 hráčů lvbet kasino žádné bonusové kódy vkladu kasinový automat na mince 300 hřiven dobré pokerové názvy alf kasino promo kód zprávy o kasinu virginia www.poker stars.uk kasino mamaia nord kniha online her zdarma ra 2 jackpot sloty uk online poker stránky uk pop sloty kódy točení zdarma profesionální pokerový stůl pokerové žetony monte carlo uk sportovní bonusový kód pokerstars zítra rajská křídla kasino domgame žádný vklad kasino el royale žádný vklad bonusové kódy 2020 888 kasino živý chat dohazovač dohazovač karaoke promo kódy kasina playamo 2020 online obchod s ovocem promo kód kasina argo flopzilla crack keygen parkoviště nejblíže kasinu v Paříži body karetní hry v kasinu red hot poker závod na prodej u mě 888 kasinových pokerových heren poker nl5 sazka mobil sance kontrola tiketu zákaz závad v kasinu gta 5 roztočení zdarma kasino bez vkladu pokerové stránky hrají online online kasino bonus za registraci bez vkladu omaha4rollz highstakesdb slayerv1fan pokerové laboratoře Monte Carlo kasino Monako hrací automaty kniha bonusu ra žádný vklad poker tony guoga strategie pokerového turnaje online všimněte si pokeru ruka 2 poznámky zdarma vyhrajte auto v kasinu gta nejlepší kasino bonus s vkladem grand viktoriánský hotel maine amatic sloty zdarma ke stažení nejlepší pokerové aplikace v Indii lord lucky casino uk čísla sportky dnes Villa Fortuna žádné vkladové kódy 2019 geneze kasinových planet party poker bonus bez vkladu 2018 sazka výsledky kasino modane drive casio w218h červená výherní automaty čísla dnešní sportky top 10 kasino slotů uk hodnocení webových stránek kasina casino kajot ostrava dostihy a sazky kone cena žolík pokerová karetní hra webová řada kasino 2020 znovuotevření kasina v Arizoně automat kajot pátek casinoorg 50 $ zdarma bitstarz kasino recenze thepogg zdarma kasinové kostkové hry výkonný ředitel kasina Red Rock umírá kasino romantické knihy justin smith pokerový hráč bonusové kódy pro červené jelení kasino 2020 alf kasino bonus bez vkladu poker online idn bonus nový člen 30 ept pokerové turnaje 2019 bonusový kód kasina karamba 2018 pouštní diamantové online kasino alf kasino bez vkladových bonusových kódů stáhnout poker hru APK bonusové kódy kasina Grand Eagle 2020 jak vydělat peníze v gta 5 online guvernér pokeru 3 žetony zdarma sazka sportka mimořádné losování bonusový kód tivoli casino 2020 poker 94 úroveň 13 tipy na sázení online kasinových her fortuna výsledky fotbal 8členný pokerový stůl pokerová strategie texas holdem pdf kasino atlantis poker vstupní stránky kasina ostrov capri kasino jezero charles vyhrát poker mrtvý povstání 2 dobré pokerové knihy reddit ráj pokerové kasino kasino fórum pravidla minimální sázky na poker dostihy a sázky návod peníze fortuna automaty zdarma pronájem recepční v kasinu hry pro děti online lego víno kasino hra alternativní odkaz pokerpelangi texas holdem vládne blindům recenze online kasina skycity svetr James Bond Casino Royale kontrola tiketu velké dolarové kasino 200 $ bonusové kódy bez vkladu 2019 cheat pro čtyři krále a sloty ps4 cheaty soundtrack k filmu z kasina youtube losování karty 5 poker ruská ruleta casino bonus bez počátečního vkladu 2020 automaty zdarma ke stažení seznam pokerových podmínek ustanovení hry pro rok 2018-19 zdarma kasino sloty aplikace gta 5 online kasino aktualizovat auta recenze kasina drueckglueck sportka náhodný tip poker atd texas holdem poker ke stažení pc hry fortuna výsledky loterií super mario bros 2 bonusová šance online blackjack v kasinu živě panda kasino las vegas velké dolarové kasino bez bonusových kódů říjen 2019 nové čisté kasino bez bonusu všechny rozsahy kasina mimo body gta jak hrát kasino hadí oči youtube jnandez plo mobilní telefony samsung hud pokertracker pokerstars automat na ovoce hry herní pas hry na mobil ke stažení zdarma samsung sazka tah 13.12 velké kasino pokloňte se pokerové ruce kasino 2019 bonus bez vkladu nejlepší online hráči pokeru 2020 zlaté kasino las vegas žádný vkladový bonus 5 liber zdarma všechny sloty kasino nový zéland šťastná recenze kasina vip pokerové hvězdy uk stáhnout čísla sportky podle data narození intertops klasické kasino bez vkladu bonus 2018 alf kasino bonus bez vkladu 2019 sazka výběr výhry Pestana Casino Park Hotel Funchal Madeira recenze nové online kasino bez vkladu bonusové kódy 2020 Grand Casino Hotel & Resort Oklahoma Výběr z kasina tipico není možný paypal casino neu okada pokerový turnaj 2020 ferguson poker rychlé výběry v kasinu bankid online kasino s bonusem zdarma auto Grand Victoria na prodej kapitán vaří kasino uk přihlásit se kasino Dublin 1 kasinové hry casanova Plán znovuotevření kasina mgm kasino san marino poker baccarat tisíc nocí 18 světelný lustr hráčský klub kasino ventura miniclip poker texas holdem blockova loterie cz diamantové výherní hry zdarma kasinové kostkové hry online bufet se stolními horami novomatická burza MacBook Pro nebo Air online kasino belgie s bezplatnými počátečními penězi gta online jak vydělat peníze partycaption pokerstrategy online test nebezpečí synottip.cz automatické halloweenské štěstí bonus kasina synottip kasino bonus o skutečné peníze 2020 Stažení pokerových pokerových hráčů texas hold'em & omaha casio pt 100 hry na mobil zdarma Webové stránky s hazardními hrami Skywind bwin poker aplikace pro Android ke stažení peněžní seznam hlavní události wsop 2019 alan kocovina poker gif aplikace truecaller cena degustačního menu na terase kasina benjamin heath poker softwarové společnosti v kasinu film komik 8 kasinových králů kasino adrenalin žádný bonus bonusový kód kasino zdarma výlet s diamantovou hlavou casino765 žádné bonusové kódy vkladu korunový kasino asx kód hrajte eurojackpot online le kasino monte carlo gta 5 kasino vip Žebříčky pokerových hráčů online kasino život poker uplatnit kódy poker omaha ruční trenér pokerová jména karet nejlepší online kasino ve Velké Británii žolíková karetní pokerová hra online online pokerový superuživatel sloty kasinové hry hotelový grant kasino choctaw Pokerstars Championship Monte Carlo koupit vegascasino.io poker fold equity kalkulačka terminál sazky ostrava ano mobilní kasino myb kasino bonus bez vkladu kajot casino apk download pouštní diamantové kasino glendale arizona sazka hry bonus výběr hotovosti netticasino poker petersham rsl nápady na pokerovou párty černá ředkev v angličtině karetní poker streamování pokergo zdarma banco casino bratislava kasinové hry zdarma živé fórum kasinových webů krypto kotouče kasino žádné bonusové kódy vkladu online kasino royale dailymotion sledovač pokerových špionů sázení stromy sázka arena poker room twitter platit penězi sazka sportka kontrola hong kong kasino nsw Bonus v kasinu 1 euro 2019 online kasino s reálnými penězi kasino du liban poker 2020 Doubleu Casino zdarma promo kódy diamant joes zodiac casino mobile uk http // www.pokerstars.com obrázky k narozeninám v kasinu warnetqq důvěryhodná online pokerová stránka s hazardními hrami bandarq dominoqq ept prague winner a smith poker hendon komunitní zdravotní středisko v kasinu Hrajte sloty novoline zdarma plán ept monte carlo 2019 mirage kasinová ohňová show luxusní pokerový účet seznam her fortuna nabidka dnes je poker hazardních her nebo dovednostní hra zdarma kódy kasina doubleu poker propagační akce maryland live kasinové restaurace otevřené v Las Vegas stahuj hry zdarma na pc plane verze lobby kasina uptown nejlepší bonus v kasinu online omáčka123 nejlepší online australské kasino 2019 kajot poker praha turnaje mr green App Store kasino téma narozeninové party dekorace je kasino s kamennou propastí otevřené 24 hodin automat hrat zdarma oasis polka dot šaty bílé mads mikkelsen poker face kasina v čr město hazardu v ms streamování pokeru naživo online blackjack live dealer skutečné peníze party poker česká republika systém ruleta vám trubice bonus kasina betfair sazka plný tiket recenze kasina panda Hrajte knihu ra online zdarma las vegas kasino pracovník plat složit pokerový termín casino magic planet gold na poříčí mobilní sázka 365 cy vyslanec kasina praha TripAdvisor James Bond Casino Royale Elenco rozsah online kasina gta je mimo nejlepší slot Kings kasino turnaje v české republice americky poker hra zdarma bonus Fortuna Pane, hrajte sázkovou kancelář hrát zdarma kasinové video výherní automaty es kasino ve španělštině kasino film navod jak vyhrat sportku kniha hracích automatů ra zdarma kasino se skutečnými penězi mit paypal pokerstars thajsko legální bonus zdarma kasino bez vkladu pppoker aplikace hack kazino inetbet kasino bonus bez vkladu 2019 štěstí dragon kasino las vegas nejlepší kasina v kanadě online nejlepší evropské online kasino poker kočka pokerbooks.pl nelepivý bonus znamená kasino bwin online opičí pokerový termín automat online zdarma da bar zynga poker apk hack aktualní jackpot sportky mapa kasina royale las vegas znovuotevření kasina maryland kasinové hry bwin točit a hogc hcmc témata výzkumu kasina winpalace hotel arbanasi kasino poblíž Eureka ca. holandské kasino scheveningen hrát poker bonusy kasina skrill sportka mimoradna slosovani Grand Ivy Casino bezplatný kód pokerstars král kasino černé a bílé pokerstars Texas Holdem Poker zdarma žetony a kasino zlato sportka plný tiket cena 2019 mobilní klimatizace Desert Diamond Casino online hry kde se da hrat poker online svět vegas - hrajte online kasinové hry pro zábavu ve světě vegas výherní noviny královské spinz kasino přihlášení nejnovější online automaty zdarma na rok 2020 888poker.es přihlášení olympijské kasino online lv robinho pokerstars je kasino europa legální ve Spojených arabských emirátech šance las vegas rytíři otevírací doba geant kasino aurillac německé online kasino žádný vklad bonus nejlepší kasino v Nizozemsku 6black recenze kasina kasino film netflix uk novomatic uk kasino hrací automat online kanada poznámka k mobilní platbě jungleman12 plný náklon nejlepší online kasina se skutečnými penězi casino mariánské lázně mobilní kasino titan nejlepší poker hud pokerstars logo koruny kasina png gem twist kasino online hazard s hrou zdarma zimní série pokerstars 2018 pravidla plo8 pokerstars Nintendo Switch Pokerstars vzorec indexu volatility slotů dvojité kasinové hry mobilní pohotovost brno polykat poker význam recenze betfair casino nj aplikace kasinových her sázka na nejistotu online rozvrh pokeru blackhawk online kasino výběr paypal usa tesla poker 218 mod eucasino 1981 corvette automatická převodovka leovegas casino quora nejlepší kasina v kraji san diego americký poker 3 zdarma pokerová video aplikace martin kabrhel poker kasino 24/24 paříž poker 13 karet online loupež kasina nejlepší přístup reddit zaručené online kasino Harmonogram světové série pokeru na rok 2019 zdarma online kasinové výherní hry bez stahování nejlepší online kasino bez vkladu bonus USA laboratoře xflixx poker pro http // www.pokerstars.net / ru / nabídka kasina jackson online pokerová tvář kontakt na kasino kaya artemis miliony pokerových pokerových výsledků do roku 2020 kasinové hry bez bonusu za vklad pracovní doba kasina ptuj kasino sloty online hry zdarma kasino diskotéka bonus bez vkladu hrát kasino bez povolení licence Klíčové slovo o křížovce živý přenos kasina na youtube zlaté euro kasino bez vkladových bonusových kódů 2020 živý prodejce online kasina blackjack pane kousnutí fika kasino hvězdy slot facebook mobilní kasino mr žádný vklad datum vydání kasina gta 5 dlc Golden Nugget Casino Las Vegas Nevada celkové kasino v goa kasino770 zdarma python poker kalkulačka kurzů kasinové hry ke stažení zdarma Fallout umístění nové šance vegasgas lovci lovu pokeru kasino 10 roztočení zdarma bez vkladu pinnacle casino atlantické město sazka vysledky dnes kniha deluxe stažení zdarma sedni a jdi čaroděj 3 peníze za like na facebooku 18 let staré pokerové turnaje lesní kasino youtube online hry zdarma poker texas jackmillion kasinové kupóny promo kód kasina kasino netent bonusové kódy rozsah gta v kasinu je mimo zdarma spinner kasino bingo propagace pokerstars pa uzamčení kasinové policie nejlepší kasino v Evansville v Indii ip číslo kasina Světová série pokerové vítěze hlavní události roku 2018 kasina na jihu tenerife pytel hadrů epizody webových seriálů kasina automatizace procesů gta v kasino loupež diamanty hodnoty pokerových žetonů pro domácí hru poker holdem online hry 2013 pc hrací automaty na prodej v mém okolí stáhnout poker v hry vklad do online kasina bonus 1 euro online stránka s dominoqq hazardními hrami turnajový poker ept 2020 asijské kasinové výherní hry Vložte 1 euro kasino 2019 paypal martin kabrhel boxrec baccarat rouge 540 vzorků wsop 2019 stream reddit olybet pokerová aplikace v pořádku kasinové bonusové kódy kasinové hry zdarma hrát knihu ra dublinbet kasino žádný vklad kasino v kasinu křížovka 1 hodina kasina zdarma kasino poblíž split chorvatsko joker 81 kajot online durrrr poker casio wr50m akcie kasina a hotelu zdarma video poker 770 význam pokerového srdce nejlepší web pro online poker s přáteli Victory Casino Cruise Port Canaveral recenze hrajte poker s přáteli online zdarma sledovač turnajů texas holdem wifi poker místnost iphone kasino euromoon bez bonusu za vklad 2018 1. sezóna pokerových superhvězd mega vyhrát sloty nejnovější verze domino qq topfun split kasino admirála uk kasino klub přihlásit
 
Common Law Review
 
Dom

Pihlen






Zapomenut heslo

Syndikovn

12: Linda Krkorov - Abortion Law in the United States PDF Tisk E-mail

Abortion Law in the United States

State Interest and the Right of Privacy

Linda Krákorová

 

A single woman from Texas finds herself pregnant. A joyful event for most, an unpleasant surprise for others. Having a child was nothing the woman desired at that time and it seemed there was no remedy available to her. What she wanted was to be allowed freely to decide whether or not to obtain an abortion. Unfortunately for her, this freedom of choice was something the state in which she lived sought to limit. The woman decided to fight for the rights she believed to have and brought her case to court. Her name was Norma McCorvey but it was her legal name that has become renowned: as “Jane Roe.” Norma McCorvey challenged the constitutionality of the Texas criminal abortion laws and marked the American legal history in the area of abortion law.

 

US Abortion Law as Time Goes by

            The abortion law existed, at first, as a part of the common law inherited from England. Abortion after quickening[1] (about 15-18 weeks) was a crime under English common law and it was punished severely. Its legal qualification slightly varied in different times. Early common law regarded abortion as felony – a hanging offense and the “Father of common law,” Henry Bracton,[2] held that abortion was homicide. Its successors, Coke and Blackstone, were not so convinced of abortion’s nature as a murder, but they thought abortion after quickening was a crime of its own – a grave misprission. Although after-quickening abortion was strictly criminalized, it remains unclear, whether pre-quickening abortion was criminalized as well. In 1803, England introduced a statutory abortion scheme in the Miscarriage of Woman Act[3] and thus rooted abortion criminalization in a statutory law.

In the early 1820’s American states began the codification of the common law inherited from England including abortion law, then a part of criminal law. The legal regulation of abortion was not dealt with on a federal level by any statute valid for and enforceable in all the states. Every state approached it in its own way, though they would all, to a lesser or greater degree, follow the English pattern when dealing with abortion.

The first state to pass a specific abortion law was Connecticut in 1821, followed by New York in 1828. The rest of the states followed and the codification process did not cease until the 1850’s. Although the laws criminalized abortion from the very beginning, the regulation became even more rigid in 1860 when England established a uniform abortion prohibition and was followed by a major part of the United States. Such was the existing state until the second half of the 20th century. Abortion was prohibited with health exceptions, i.e. an abortion in respect to preserve the mother’s life. It was not until the 1960’s and the 1970’s that rape, incest and some further health exceptions were included and the tight abortion regulation relaxed. Still, the fundamental upheaval was yet to come.

The call for democracy and liberalisation in this area brought radical changes to state laws. Cases appearing before courts called for the limitation of the state interference with individual constitutional rights. The concept of abortion law suddenly acquired an entirely new dimension. The abortion laws passed until now independently by every state, began to be challenged on the grounds of their alleged lack of compliance with the U.S. Constitution. The question being whether the choice to have an abortion is a woman’s exclusive right as guaranteed by the Constitution or whether it lacks any constitutional backing and is, therefore, at the mercy of state legislatures.

Cases eventually reached the U.S. Supreme Court, the legal opinions of which are binding upon all the courts of the country. The issue of abortion became a matter of federal importance and interest. Numerous Supreme Court decisions rendered void the laws previously valid in various states. The Court created yet another body of abortion law and it began to dominate the subject. Those cases which reached the Supreme Court and were successful, narrowed the area in which the state legislatures were allowed to regulate abortion in any way and the state legislatures found themselves with their hands tied.

What the cases tried to prove was that abortion was, in fact, a constitutional right. The year 1973 brought a genuine revolution in the U.S. abortion law. This was when Roe v. Wade came before the courts and a woman’s choice to seek abortion was declared part of the constitutional right of privacy. Two more cases of comparable importance were yet to come. Webster (1989) and Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) slightly departed from Roe but were careful not to overrule it. The latter two enabled the states legislatures to regulate abortion more freely, expanding the tiny room left after Roe.

 

Abortion Case Law/Cases in Action

The abortion cases tend to follow the same pattern: a pregnant woman seeking abortion, obstetricians or an organization defending the woman’s rights sue their state claiming that its abortion laws are unconstitutional in that they violate or oppose a right contained in any of the constitutional amendments. There were many cases before and after Roe. In all the cases significant aspects of the state abortion laws were pointed to.

In Poe v. Ullman (1961)[4] the Supreme Court dismissed the challenge to a Connecticut criminal statute prohibiting the use and counselling regarding the use of contraceptives. In Griswold v. Connecticut (1965)[5] a Connecticut law banning distribution, use, etc., of contraceptives was voided. The court developed the penumbra (shadow) doctrine which claimed that there are more constitutional rights than those enumerated in the Constitution and that if one seeks, he may find another constitutional right between the gaps. Eight years later, the court in Roe premised their decision on similar grounds and subsumed the right to abortion into the right of privacy.

United States v. Vuitch (1971)[6] was one of the cases where the claimants attacked the health exceptions, a term used frequently in abortion laws, for being too vague. Although the claimants shielded themselves with the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution and the concept of due process, they had no success. The case did not consider any privacy claims, as Roe later would. Eisenstadt v. Baird (1972)[7] put an end to a Massachusetts statute prohibiting the distribution of contraceptives by anyone other than doctors and pharmacists to married persons. The court argued that such law violates the equal protection clause by discriminating against unmarried people. It is now 1973 and Roe v. Wade[8] comes to dominate the scene.

 

Roe v. Wade in Action

Ms. Roe believed that Texas criminal abortion laws violated one of her constitutional rights. In her view, it was the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. This Amendment guaranteed all citizens’ rights to privacy against any state interference. The majority of judges agreed with her reasoning. Roe v. Wade (1973) was the first case to subsume the woman’s right to terminate her pregnancy into the right of privacy and thus to declare the right to abortion a constitutional right. Nevertheless, the state was not deprived entirely of the possibility of protecting its interests, i.e. the woman’s health and the potentiality of human life. The judges in Roe developed a trimester framework which favours the individual right or the state’s legitimate interest according to the stage the pregnancy has reached. Before the end of the first trimester, the only individual able to prevent the abortion is the woman’s physician, the state has no power to regulate abortion at this stage whatsoever. After the first trimester, the state may intervene to protect the mother’s health. Finally, in stages subsequent to viability (the child would be able to live outside the mother’s womb) “the State, in promoting its interest in the potentiality of human life, may, if it chooses, regulate, and even proscribe, abortion except where necessary, in appropriate medical judgement, for the preservation of the life or health of the mother.“[9]

Roe proved its colossal impact when abortion laws of nearly every state were voided by the decision. It was then, that abortion law experienced an important shift as to its sources.

 

Roe Overruled?

Roe has continued to be hailed the seminal case in the U.S. abortion law due in large part to the consequences the decision brought. Until today, important decisions appear before the courts that constantly change the concept. Doe v. Bolton (1973)[10] strikes down those parts of Georgia statute, which dealt with health, rape and incest exceptions. The judges held, that a woman has a constitutional right to abortion from six months to birth, if her doctor finds it necessary for her physical or mental health. Planned Parenthood of Central Missouri v. Danforth (1976).[11]

The first sharp departure from Roe came with Webster v. Reproductive Health Services (1989).[12] The court held that the trimester framework ought to be discarded, because the state has a compelling interest in fetal life throughout pregnancy. Although the judges did not follow Roe, nor did they overrule it. A similar situation comes about in 1992. Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992)[13] was careful not to overturn Roe, still here we see Roe the closest in its history to being overruled.

In 1982 the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act was to take effect. Before it actually did so, five abortion clinics, a physician and a class of doctors who provided abortion services, brought a suit with the object of having certain parts of the act declared unconstitutional. There were five provisions, which, in the petitioners’ view, burdened a woman seeking abortion with too great a duty to provide information, and were, therefore, unconstitutional. The challenged provisions required that a woman seeking an abortion give her informed consent prior to the procedure and that she be provided with certain information at least 24 hours before the abortion is performed; another provision mandates the informed consent of one parent for a minor to obtain an abortion; the third demands that a married woman seeking an abortion must notify her husband; the fourth defines „medical emergency“ so as to excuse compliance with the foregoing requirements; and other provisions impose certain reporting demands on facilities providing abortion services.

            The judges in this case justified the claimants’ opinion in one aspect only – no husband’s consent to his wife’s abortion may be required. Such demand was held unconstitutional. Judges applied the so-called undue burden standard, which would consider providing such information an excessive obstacle for a woman seeking abortion. Where the judges departed from Roe was in refusing to retain the trimester framework. They considered it much too rigid and preferred a somewhat more vague borderline between the relevant stages whilst protecting the woman’s choice of having the abortion prior to viability. “Overruling Roe’s central holding would not only reach an unjustifiable result under stare decisis principles, but would seriously weaken the Court’s capacity to exercise the judicial power and to function as the Supreme Court of a Nation dedicated to the rule of law.”[14]

 

The U.S. Abortion Law 2001

The majority opinion in Webster suggested that “a woman’s interest in having an abortion is a form of liberty protected by the due process clause, but States may regulate abortion procedures in ways rationally related to a legitimate state interest.”[15] Roe, together with Doe and Casey, significantly narrowed the sphere of action of the state with respect to abortion laws. Until today, almost every state does have some sort of abortion regulation. Some of the states have even never replaced, now unenforceable, general abortion bans, voided by Roe or the requirement of spousal consent or notice struck down by Casey. Today’s abortion laws usually concentrate on post-viability bans, partial-birth abortion bans, informed consent, licensed physician requirement, etc.

 

The Apple of Discord

The abortion issue has always been an utterly controversial one. On one side, there is the constitutional right the woman believes to have in respect to abortion, clashing with the laws of individual states, that have been an attempt to regulate the problem. It is obvious that the abortion controversiality lies in its, let us call it, emotionality. What ones regard as homicide depriving a potential life of the chance to be born, others view as the mother’s chance to right her mistake and have a child when the time is right for her, as for her – now impatiently awaited – offspring. In this article, however, the question, points elsewhere.

The adversaries try to find backing for their arguments in law. While anti-abortion opinion used to correspond with the content and aim of state laws, abortion advocates went further. They sought protection against the state laws in the Constitution, a set of legal rules sacred to and worshipped by American citizens, as well as, looked up to by admirers of democratic establishments, as the highest guarantee of one’s liberties and a huge milestone in the development of American democracy. The struggle continues. Is the mother the one who always gets the best for her child? Has the state the right to decide whether she has this power or not? If the state does not fight for the child, who will then? But what right does it have to interfere with the mother’s personal life? Where does her personal life end and give its way to the state’s interest?

The apple of discord was succinctly illustrated in 1972 when Justice Brennan Jr. delivered his opinion in the Eisenstadt case,[16] “If the right of privacy means anything, it is the right of the individual, married or single, to be free from unwarranted government intrusion into matters so fundamentally affecting a person as the decision whether to bear or beget a child.” If Ms. Roe achieves the performance of these words, her mission will have been successful.

 

------------------------------------------------

Linda Krákorová is a fourth-year student at the Charles University Law Faculty in Prague. She is a member of the Editorial Board of the Common Law Review.



[1] The first motion of the fetus in the womb felt by the mother, occurring usually about the middle of the term of pregnancy.

[2] (1216-1272).

[3] Lord Ellenborough‘s Act, 43 Geo. 3, c.58.

[4] 367 U.S. 497.

[5] 381 U.S. 470.

[6] 402 U.S. 62.

[7] 405 U.S. 438.

[8] 410 U.S. 113, 93 S.Ct. 705, 35 L.Ed.2d 147.

[9] Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113, 93 S.Ct. 705, 35 L.Ed.2d 147 (1973), pp. 163-165.

[10] 410 U.S. 179.

[11] 428 U.S. 52.

[12] 492 U.S. 490.

[13] 505 U.S. 833.

[14] Planned Parenthood v. Casey, No. 91-744, Justice O‘Connor, Justice Kennedy and Justice Souter delivering opinion, pp. 864-869.

[15] supra, p. 966.

[16] Eisenstadt at 453.

 
< Pedch.   Dal >