Warning: is_writable() [function.is-writable]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/php-tmp/upload) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 348

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361
cbd oil extract juice honolulu cbd cannabinoid receptors located is cbd vape oil legal for cdl drivers cbd rich hemp oil australia medical cbd oil zamnesia truffles cbd oil extract for sale dabs wax cbd oil extract for sale dabs york buy cannabidiol extract ukraine hemp oil with cbd zealand campground cannabidiol schedule b number cbd rich hemp oil qualities medical cbd lotion haze sbd deutschland yahoo site cbd hemp oil near me pizza are hemp oil products legal in idaho ontario american shaman cbd hemp oil review cbd oil with thc just chillin cbd pills cannabidiol for pain cbd oil vape pens in austin cbd oil benefits que es economia making thc cbd oils in dallas cbd cannabis oil x dab rigs medical cbd marijuana cbd hemp oil benefits gold where to get cbd oil zealand denmark where can i get cbd oil with thc for sale cbd and thc oil high smoke benefits of cbd hemp oil wholesalers vape cbd oil vaping dosage cannabidiol for sale albuquerque nm cbd oil from hemp reviews on hemp cbd oil for cancer uk how to make cbd oil without thc calculator where to buy cbd in florida cbd oil vs hash oil seed cbd and other meds like lyrica cbd cannabis news texas hemp oil products cbd marijuana cbd oil information texas legal services cbd pills information cbd cannabis medical benefits cbd vape oil in texas high cbd oil for sale in canada hemp oil extraction salary cbd oil vape oil cbd oil benefits 2016 cancer hemp oil products high in cbd low in thc cbd and thc oil missouri secretary cbd tablets limited brands cannabis cbd oil zealand slippers cbd cannabis research south beach diet book quiche recipe cannabidiol hemp oil australia pty cbd medical haze feminised seeds cannabidiol rich hemp oil cbd cannabis crystals are called cbd extraction co2 methods medical cbd oil high reviews cbd vape oil effects cbdoilsvape what is cannabidiol vaping memes hemp cbd oil for cancer kentucky cbd cannabis oil kills cancer memes sbd deutschland 83 tv cbd oil for dogs with arthritis hemp cbd oil benefits thyroid medication buy cbd vape uk jam south beach diet new book supplement warehouse cbd vape high cbd hemp oil spokane reviews cbd vape oil florida best cbd cancer treatment dosage cbd dispensary in miami florida cbd from hemp nutrition analysis cbd extraction method best cbd products sydney restaurants zagat topical cbd oil for headaches pure brand cbd tincture benefits cbd rich hemp oil for vaporizer gel cbd medical applications of radiation cbd hemp oil uses mlm business are hemp oil products legal in idaho ky cbd oil for sale holland hemp oil low thc high cbd the best cbd oil to buy uk tickets cbd hemp oil for sale vape review youtube cbd vape oil store in los angeles cbd extract oil x dab song the best cbd oil depression treatment cbd oil from cannabis research 2016 cb dipole antenna instructions hemp oil and cbd oil cannabinoid oils for cancer and arthritis vegetarian buy medical cbd oil pa cbd oil extract buy uk basketball cbd oil buy parkinson's disease life expectancy cbd oil zero thc marijuana cbd oil effects on warfarin hit cbd extract oil kills cancer on contact medicinal hemp oil epilepsy treatment hemp cbd oil benefits juices dewalt storage cups for wix cbd oil for pain zoloft reviews allowable cbd in hemp oil reviews cbd rich hemp oil qualities in soap cbd hemp oil uses quickly lower marijuana cbd strain chart cbd oil extract for sale dabs legal cbd marijuana oils buy cbd vape oil vs acrylic paint pure cbd extract thc to make candy real cbd oil vape juice high cbd oil with low thc edibles cbd vape oil wholesale cbd oil products vape shops hemp oil extract skin buy cbd hemp oil epilepsy symptoms cbd medicine tell me about it cbd hemp clones nz best cbd oil nzxt hemp oil with cbd online coupons cbd hemp oil mlm companies miracle products cbd oil zone buy cbd oil online wholesale cbd cannabis tea effects buy cbd oil wholesale epilepsy cbd drops side effects cbd hemp oil for sale epilepsy medication medical marijuana cbd oil zamnesia webshop are cbd drops legal do cbd drops get you high buy cbd wax cbd oil zamnesia credibility cbd hemp farms thc cbd vape oil cartridges cbd drops concentrate 1000 mg used cbd vapor oil effects on the economy where can i buy cbd oil kit hemp cbd complex honey cannabis oil cbd amazon the best cbd oil for eczema skin cbd and thc oil gold cbd oil extract ncaa cannabinoid oil scheduler cbd oil without thc youtube music videos recipe for cbd oil cannabidiol oil vape health organic cannabidiol hemp oil nutiva buy cbd vape oil europe stocks cbd oil vape store nyc cbd hemp oil uses effects of alcohol high cbd cannabis oil seeds extraction what cbd is good for autism buy cbd online application form hemp oil cbd treat autism child cbd hemp xli cbd side effects 200ml acdc tour buy medical cbd oil in australia where to buy cbd rich oils you can ingest cbd oil price at walmart cbd vape oil high strength magnets cbd medical haze reviews hemp cbd oil for cancer how to use cbd naturals water cbd cannabinoid oil and bone cancer cbd hemp oil uses neuroma of the foot cbd oil high just chill out cbd oil vape wattage hemp extract cbd dose for autism medical marijuana cbd oil pictures healing ms cancer cbd oil benefits 2016 of high cbd oil information juice beauty where to buy cbd rich oils quickly ripen cbd oil high kills cancer cbd oil vape buys miracle products cbd oil treatment medicinal hemp oil products for sale usa thc and cbd oil young living cbd oil for seizures adults cbd oil extract utah high cbd cannabis oil xanax addiction medical cbd oil vape juice hemp oil extract qualities where to buy cbd rich oils benefits of cider high cbd cannabis oil seeds processing cbd oil effects for anxiety cbd hemp oil uses quinoa flakes cbd oil law in oklahoma dewalt ds 150 tough system storage unit cbd hemp oil for sale diabetes test real cbd oil buy uk cbd from hemp yellow emperor acupuncture benefits of cbd oil 2016 pure cbd tincture liquid iodine cbd hemp oil buy at whole foods jobs cbd oil without thc to get cbs by the pool cbd hemp oil for anxiety south beach diet book yams and sweet cbd extract oil kills cancer stem cbd hemp health technologies benefits of cbd vape oil cartridges buy cbd oil wholesale web cbd oil vapor reviews best cbd products lunch sydney cbd oil depression cbd hemp oil just chill products cbd naturals nano water where can i buy it hemp cbd oil benefits depression help cbd hemp oil schedule 1 drug cbd oil extract for sale dabs or cbd thc oil vape temp cbd oil with thc pain cream south beach diet book quick and easy cookbook recipes effects of cbd cannabinoid cancer cbd oil for pain que es el cbd extract oil young living cannabis oil cbd youtube cnn cbd and thc oil for adhd in mississippi xml cbd cannabis legal in canada cbd oil hemp versus cannabis science thc vs cbd chart hemp oil with cbd benefits testimonials cannabidiol cbd rich hemp oil cbd cannabis for sale hemp oil products youtube cancer twenty mmj high cbd strains in los angeles cbd buy ukrainian medical marijuana and cbd oil thc hemp oil with cbd from canada organic pure cbd oil australia international cbd and thc oil texas cbd oil without thc youtube cbd medicine tell me about it expression medical marijuana cbd questions for citizenship cannabis cbd products zaden hoog cbd hemp oil benefits quotes about change medical marijuana and cbd oil pills cbd hemp oil amazon cbd hemp oil uses drug test sbd incorporated san jose car cbd oil benefits zealander cbd and thc oil nozzle are hemp oil products legal in idaho georgia cbd extracts schedule 1 niv cbd pills labels qld sbd deutschland yahoo de cbd extracts schedule 1 game buy cbd paste for lyme cbd from hemp made vans where to find cbd oil zamnesia mushrooms sagely hemp cbd cream what is cannabidiol vaping cheap where to buy cbd rich oils ukraine where to buy cbd rich oils recipe cards r4 high cbd cannabis strain best cbd thc oil effects pure brand cbd tincture epilepsy cbd oil information oklahoma hemp oil extract testimonials for friends benefits of cbd tincture epilepsy cannabidiol hemp oil ebay philippines cbd oil good for migraines cbd oil gets me higher pure cbd tincture infused waters where can i get cbd oil australian cbd oil vape shops for anxiety cbd oil benefits wikipedia español all natural cbd vape oil cbd thc oil zealand flip-flops cbd hemp oil uses nz cbd rich hemp oil for pain relief cbd vapor oil in houston tx automobiles cbd hemp oil uses dropshippers cbd cannabis leaves thc and cbd oil percentages in soap buy cbd crystal ball hemp oil cbd and diabetes medicinal hemp oil for sale in calloway cbd oil with thc zamnesiavaporizingmushrooms is cbd vape oil legal in missouri cbd oil tablets uk review hemp oil extract zazzle cbd and thc oil pain pure cbd tincture testimonials page medical marijuana cbd only edibles cannabidiol oil for seizures where to find cbd oil que es cultura south beach diet book reviews cbd thc extract best cbd products breakfast near miracle products cbd oil vape cbd oil extract buy uk how to use cbd oil for seizures pure cbd tincture reviews of la cbd hemp oil vape effects on lungs cbd hemp oil patch zero buy cbd vape and oil kit tasty hemp oil tasty cbd vape oil for sale cbd supplement xpress resler cbd hemp oil uses seizures after stroke cbd oil information epilepsy medication what are the benefits from cbd oil cbd oil products with thc in them cbd hemp oil uses anxiety test cbd thc oil zoloft reviews the cbd shop kansas city what can cbd cure prostate high cbd cannabis oil and cancer cbd oil for sale georgia south africa cbd drops qld school cbd vs thc wax cartridges cbd medicine tell me about it hax where to buy cbd oil in amsterdam best cbd vape oil for pain how to use cbd oil vape pen cbd hash oil drug test medical marijuana cbd oil japan best cbd products dessert pizza cbd oil buy in nh pain hemp cbd oil benefits quotes about family pure cbd oil migraines and dizziness cbd oil extract parkinson's disease symptoms dewalt storage systems hemp oil products on hair hemp cbd oil deaerator buy cbd hemp oil doseage phase 1 south beach diet food list pdf south beach diet book pdf free download xmodgames cbd hemp oil uses news 12 cbd oil vape buyers cbd products qld pure cbd oil australian cbd cannabis oil denver does cbd oil drug test hemp oil products zealander latest cannabidiol for anxiety medicinal hemp oil kroger feedback best cbd products dumplings recipe pure cbd oil zentai effects of cbd marijuana and fetus buy cbd vape oil juice food list for phase 1 south beach diet buy cbd online malaysia newspapers cbd oil research nobel prize mechoulam cbd hemp oil benefits just chill products completed cbd rich hemp oil for vaporizer amazon just chill products cbd oil where can i get cbd oil xanax addiction thc cbd oil kannaway cbd and other meds like concerta are cbd products legal cannabis cbd cream cannabis oil cbd versus thc detox dewalt parts storage box cbd hemp oil benefits mlm business cbd oil extract canada cbd oil for pain for dogs xbox cbd oil products legal in all 50 states cbd oil products zenmate marijuana high cbd no thc oil cbd from hemp quilting where to buy cbd concentrate extraction cbd pills labels for jars phase 1 south beach diet menu cbd no thc for sale cbd oil pain xanax bars sol cbd oil extract supplement medicinal hemp oil for sale in cape cbd vape oil for sleep cbd from hemp drug cbd oil products kentucky vaping cbd oil reddit nfl can high cbd cannabis oil be used for pain cbd hemp oil uses anxiety medication cbd from hemp nutrition information where to buy cbd e-liquid online cbd oil information penny side effects of cbd vape oil without propylene cbd hemp oil holland and barrett hemp oil with cbd from canada high pure cbd oil cannabidiol for pain cannabis cbd products review buy cbd oil wholesale does best cbd products gymnastic hemp cbd oil uk cbd vapor oil ph level marijuana cbd oil with no thc high cbd medical marijuana cbd oil kopenhaven how to take cbd oils and seizures thc and cbd oil now legal cbd oil legal ukraine cbd oil uk law schools cbd rich hemp oil vape review cbd vape oil with thca benefits south beach diet book vs online application medical marijuana cbd only medical marijuana cannabidiol oil quantity transmitter cbd oil high epilepsy awareness thc and cbd oil medical grade what is cannabidiol used for cbd oil vape shops in san diego cbd hemp oil effects cannabidiol zdf medical cbd oil zoloft and alcohol pure cbd oil denver colorado cbd oil extraction process from plants high cbd oil portland oregon ks cbd hemp clones vape oil hemp cbd oil xanax generic what is cbd oil without thc level cbd oil good for anxiety cannabis oil organic cbd enriched cbd oil interactions with other meds like adderall cbd pills qld transport cbd oil amazon uk customer cannabidiol cancer prevention cbd health cbd oil extract making friends cbd oil safe to vape meme cbd oil high dose prednisone cbd drug classification where to buy cbd extract in fl thc cbd oil from cannabis denver best cbd oil for cancer made with olive oil cbd extract oil effects on water best cbd oil georgia hemp cbd oil qldt hemp oil extract cbd from cannabis where to get cbd oil jersey pure cbd oil que es economia cbd hemp oil legal to use in rhode island cannabidiol buy videos cbd oil for cancer san diego cbd vape oil denver where to find cbd oil in topeka kansas lake cbd tablets youtube cbd hemp remedies coupon cannabidiol oil benefits high cbd oil portland oregon price cbd hemp oil for sale legal document cbd thc oil zealand campground cbd oil information parkinson's disease hemp oil extraction machine cannabidiol oil illegal drugs hemp cbd vape benefits of turmeric buy cbd hemp oil doses cannabidiol hemp oil making machine cbd products australia exports cbd oil for pain eczema cannabidiol bipolar treatment cannabidiol oil how to use benefits of cbd strains that don't get you high thc cbd oil zamnesiavaporizingmushrooms cbd medical legal issues cannabinoid cbd quotes about family best cbd products melbourne breakfast places cbd products portland oregon dmv cbd medicine in uk universities cbd hemp oil patch reviews medicinal cbd oil buy colorado & company real estate cbd medical cannabis cbd oil from cannabis xanax alprazolam best cbd oil for cancer cbd hemp wax 1000 mg colorado cbd effects reddit cbd oil products ukulele cbd oil reviews for cancer hemp cbd oil benefits nzymes cbd medical word roots cbd oil buyers in texas cbd rich hemp oil quickly coupons that's natural cbd oil cbd hemp oil benefits supplement hemp oil with cbd from canada and thc high cbd cannabis oil seeds uk nuts cbd oil extract queen cbd oil effects youtube movies cbd oil products parkinson's law of management cbd oil products uk cannabidiol where to buy london cbd hemp oil benefits youtube music organic cannabis oil with cbd oil cbd thc sativa indica where to find cbd oil charlotte's web marijuana seeds for sale cbd oil extract zealand cbd buy oil cancer in uk buy cbd online malaysia tv cbd oil extract texas legal separation cbd and thc testing in blood cbd hash oil in contra costa county library medical marijuana cbd capsules benefits cbd oil without thc hash hemp oil cbd and thc cannabis effects of cbd on humans cbd oil from plant cannabis south beach diet pdf free download cbd oil for sale joints of the foot medical cbd oil uk thc vs cbd effects on immune cbd oil safe to vape and smoke cbd hemp oil benefits quotes about friendship
 
Common Law Review
 
Home arrow Articles arrow Issue 1 - The British Constitution arrow 01: Barbara Lisá - Consideration Considered: How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts
01: Barbara Lisá - Consideration Considered: How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts PDF Print E-mail

Consideration Considered

 How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts

 

Barbara Lisá

 

No legal system allows all contracts to be enforced. In every legal system, therefore, rules exist to identify which contracts are enforceable at law and which are not. In English law this function is performed mainly by the doctrine of consideration. The doctrine of consideration establishes consideration as an element for the valid formation of contracts and requires that consideration be given for a contract to exist: if there is no consideration, there is no contract. The requirement of consideration is, in part, what distinguishes contracts from gratuitous legal acts, such as gifts.

 

What is meant by the term consideration? Consideration is the price paid for the other party's obligation. It means that a promise by one party to do something for another party will not become binding unless the other party promises something in exchange. Consideration is "an act, forbearance, or promise by one party to a contract that constitutes the price for which he buys the promise of the other".[1] It is based on the idea of reciprocity. An act without consideration is not legally binding; it is a so-called naked act, which does not give rise to a right of action. The leading case of Curie v Misa[2] sets out the definition of consideration that is still used today: "Valuable consideration …[is]…some right, interest, profit or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaken by the other."

 

The doctrine of consideration sets out four requirements for consideration to be valid. The first is that the consideration must be valuable. Secondly, the consideration must be sufficient, but it does not need to be adequate. The third condition is that the consideration must move from the promisee - the person to whom the promise is made. Finally, the consideration may be executory or executed, but past consideration cannot be used to support a promise. While these four conditions are simple to state, this paper will demonstrate how complex and cumbersome they can be in their application.

 

The first requirement, that the consideration should be valuable, is particularly difficult as it has not been consistently defined by the courts. It is derived from the definition quoted above and some boundaries have been clearly established. For example, natural love and affection or the performance of a moral duty is not enough to render a promise enforceable as a contract. This is illustrated by the case of White v Bluett.[3] The court found a son's promise not to complain to his father about how the father's property was distributed among his children not to be good consideration for his father's promise not to sue his son for a debt owed to him. Judge Pollock held that the son had not provided good consideration as he had no legal right to complain. Thus, in promising not to complain, the son did not forbear or give up anything of value in exchange for his father's promise.

 

This decision can be attacked on two grounds. Firstly, it ignores the "practical benefit" the father obtained in being free of his son's complaints. This argument is supported by the recent case of Pitt v PHH Asset Management Ltd.[4] Secondly, Judge Pollock's finding that there was no right to complain can be disputed. It could be argued that, since there is no express prohibition of complaining to one's father, the son did have a right to complain and in promising to abstain from doing so he had given valuable consideration. A contemporary of the White decision, the American case of Hamer v Sidway,[5] follows this approach. 

 

Another clear characteristic of the notion of value is that it is primarily objective. Generally, the courts have held that the consideration must be of value in the eyes of the law, regardless of how it is seen in the eyes of the parties, for it to be valid. However, difficulties arise when the parties genuinely believe the promise to be good. Consider, for example, the case of Cook v Wright,[6] where the court found valid consideration to exist where one of the parties believed that it had a legally valid claim against the other party (which was later determined to have little legal merit) and reached a compromise with the other party over taking proceedings to enforce it.

 

Similarly, the law is also clear that promising to perform a duty that is already owed to the other party because it is already imposed by law or by contract does not constitute valid consideration. Promising to perform a contractual duty owed to a third party, however, can be valid consideration. This is because someone may still receive something of value even when he personally is not the ultimate beneficiary of the thing promised. The rule against allowing pre-existing contractual obligations to be used again as consideration in a later contract originated in the case of Stilk v Myrick.[7] The facts of the case are that a crew was to sail to the Baltic Sea and back to London with the defendant as a shipmaster. When two crewmen deserted, the defendant could not find replacements so he promised the remaining crew that he would distribute the wages of the deserters amongst them if they would sail back to London. After arriving in London, the defendant refused to pay the extra money and the crew brought suit. The defendant successfully argued that the crew had not provided consideration for his promise because they were already obligated to sail the ship.

 

The rule in Stilk v Myrick has been criticized as being too harsh since applying it often defeats the expectations of parties who believe their mutual promises to be binding. Several exceptions to the rule have now been developed under English law. An example is the case of Williams v Roffey Bros. & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd.[8] The defendant building contractors entered into a contract with the plaintiff sub-contractors to renovate a block of twenty-seven flats for a certain price. The plaintiffs were to receive payment after the work was completed. After renovating the roof and nine flats, the plaintiffs ran into financial difficulties, in part because the price they had charged under the contract was too low to cover the cost of the work. The defendants promised to pay the plaintiffs an additional amount for every flat completed on time. However, at the time of the deadline for completion set by the contract, the defendants refused to pay the plaintiffs the additional amount promised. Applying Stilk v Myrick, the defendants argued that the promise was not supported by consideration.

 

The Court of Appeal rejected the argument and allowed the appeal. Glidewell LJ held that, "a contractor who agrees too low a price... is acting contrary to his own interests" and accepted the reasoning of the trial judge that, "where the original sub-contract price is too low, and the parties subsequently agree that additional monies shall be paid...this agreement (i.e.: the subsequent one)[9] is in the interest of both parties". Furthermore, Glidewell LJ held that, while "the defendants may have derived...a practical benefit[10] from their agreement to pay the bonus, they derive no benefit in law, since the plaintiff promised no more than he was already bound to do by his sub-contract". This means that the performance of an existing contractual duty owed to the promisor could constitute good consideration. It remains to be seen how Williams can be reconciled with Stilk, which was not expressly overruled.

 

The nature of the value requirement becomes less certain in non-commercial settings as is illustrated by the case of Ward v Byham.[11] In that case, the father of an illegitimate child promised to pay its mother one pound per week provided that the child was well looked after and happy. When he stopped making payments, the mother brought suit. The father argued that the contract was unenforceable as the mother had not provided consideration because it was her existing legal duty to ensure that the child was well looked after and happy. Lord Denning held that the father did benefit from the mother's promise to look after the child and characterized the father's promise as a unilateral contract - a promise made in exchange for an act.

 

The discussion in the preceding paragraphs shows how complicated the case law relating to the seemingly simple requirement that the consideration should be valuable has become. A similar situation exists for the other requirements of the doctrine of consideration. A classic illustration of how the second requirement of the doctrine of consideration (i.e. that it be sufficient, although it need not be adequate) applies is provided by the case of Chappell and Co. v Nestle.[12] Nestle offered gramophone records for sale in return for 1s 6d plus three wrappers from their chocolate bars. The House of Lords held that though the wrappers were trivial in value, they were nonetheless valid consideration. Lord Somerville found that, "a contracting party can stipulate what consideration he chooses. A peppercorn does not cease to be good consideration if it is established that the promisee does not like pepper and will throw away the corn". Thus, the term adequate means "to have economic value" but does not require that it be precisely quantified. Consideration does not need to constitute a realistic price for the promise it buys as long as it has some economic value.[13]

 

The third principle of the doctrine is that the consideration must move from the promisee - the person to whom the promise is made. This is another way of stating the privity rule: consideration must be provided by the promisee who is a party to the contract. This rule is shown in the case of Tweddle v Atkinson.[14] Mr Tweddle, Jr married Ms Guy. After the marriage their fathers made a contract in which Mr Tweddle, Sr promised to give one hundred pounds to his son and Mr Guy promised to give his daughter two hundred pounds. But Mr Guy died before he could give the money to his daughter, so his consideration of two hundred pounds never moved. The executor of his estate refused to pay the money to Mr Tweddle, Jr on the ground that there was no contract between Mr Tweddle, Jr, Mr Tweddle, Sr and Mr Guy as Mr Tweddle, Jr had not provided any consideration; rather the contract was only between Mr Tweedle, Sr and Mr Guy. This rule was much criticised by judges over the years and was finally abolished by Parliament in 1999 by the passing of the Contract (Rights of Third Parties) Act.

 

The final principle of the doctrine of consideration is that the consideration may be executory or executed but not past. A bilateral contract is binding from the moment when the promises are exchanged. This form of consideration is executory because at the time the promises are given, neither party has yet undertaken performance, but both are contractually bound to perform the contract. Consideration in a unilateral contract is executed because the promise is in exchange for a performed act. Past consideration is consideration that was already provided before the promise was even made as, for example, in Stilk v Myrick cited above; in such a case there is no reciprocity.

 

Roscola v Thomas[15] illustrates the problem of past consideration. The defendant agreed to sell a horse and shortly afterwards added the promise that he would give a warranty as to the fitness of the horse. The horse was later found to be unhealthy and the plaintiff sued for breach of the warranty. The court held the defendant's promise unenforceable because the only consideration the plaintiff had provided was his entry into the original contract of sale. This occurred before the promise of fitness was made and so it was past consideration.

 

This paper has attempted to illustrate some of the difficulties associated with the doctrine of consideration, particularly with the concept of value. Recently, the doctrine has come under attack from legal scholars and some advocate its abolition. As we have seen, Parliament has just abolished one of its four requirements. Even the courts seem to be becoming critical of the doctrine, and after the decision of the Court of Appeal in Williams[16] its future in English contract law is very uncertain.

 

While the court did not attempt to throw out the doctrine, it significantly limited the rule in Stilk v Myrick[17] by emphasizing the need to identify a practical rather than a legal benefit. Courts will now be more willing to find consideration valid where doing so would reflect the intentions of the parties. This approach brings the doctrine of consideration closer to the doctrine of legal relation. If the doctrine of consideration is to be abolished, then it is for those who support such a development to formulate some other mechanism by which the boundaries of English contract law can be established.       

 

 

Barbara Lisá

Barbara Lisá, a former Vice-President of the Common Law Society, is student at Charles University Law Faculty in Prague. Between 1999 and 2001, she studied a two-year Cambridge University distance course receiving a Diploma in an Introduction to English Law and the Law of the European Union. 

 



[1] See Martin, E. A., A Concise Dictionary of Law.

[2] (1875) L.R. 10 Ex 153.

[3] (1853) 23 L.J. Ex 36.

[4] (1994) 1 W.L.R. 327.

[5] (1891) 27 N.E. 256.

[6] See Cook v Wright, (1861) 1 B&S 559.

[7] (1809) 2 Camp. 317 and 6 Esp. 129.

[8] (1991) 1 Q.B. 1.

[9] My addition to the quote.

[10] My emphasis.

[11] (1956) 1 W.L.R. 496.

[12] (1960) A.C. 87.

[13] See Martin, E. A., supra, note 1.

[14] (1861) 1 B. & S. 393.

[15] (1842) 3 Q.B. 234.

[16] Supra, note 8.

[17] Supra, note 7.

 

 

Bibliography:

Beale, H.G., Bishop, W.D. and Furmston, M.P., Contract: Cases and Materials, 3rd ed., 1995

McKendrick, E., Contract Law, 3rd ed., 1997

Smith, Sir John, Smith and Thomas: A Casebook on Contract, 10th ed., 1996

 

 

 
Next >