Warning: is_writable() [function.is-writable]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/php-tmp/upload) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 348

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/cz/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/webs/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361

Warning: file_exists() [function.file-exists]: open_basedir restriction in effect. File(/usr/local/www/wp-config.php) is not within the allowed path(s): (VIRTUAL_DOCUMENT_ROOT) in /usr/local/www/webs/cz/society/review/templates/infinitelysimple/index.php(28) : eval()'d code(1) : regexp code(1) : eval()'d code on line 361
aleve pas cher en ligne plavix pas cher achat en ligne cyklokapron posologie vente suprax antibiotic resistance vente precose generique france bupropion sr 150 mg effets secondaires lipitor pas cher en ligne pour l'emploi peut on acheter cytotec sans ordonnance vente pilex prix nitrofurantoin pas cher forum acheter metformin sr achat en ligne de carafate générique hyperthyroidie cordarone conduite tenir lithium pas chere assiette porcelaine prix du stromectol acheter buspar en france zofran pas cher forum wawa adalat inde pas cher forum achat risperdal en ligne vente de nimotop pas cher paris prednisone 5 mg gain de poids famvir pas cher forum voyage saw palmetto pas cher indeed vrai myambutol pas cher en france achat en ligne aricept quebec team vente voltaren france viramune pas cher france canada direct propecia prix moyen prednisolone pas cher france canada keflex suspension de 125 mg depakote pas cher marques houston achat celadrin en ligne canada acheter propranolol chlorhydrate d'etifoxine lamisil pas chere voyage generique viagra pas cher duphalac pas chere achat diclofenac 1% gel téva prednisone 10 mg pour la goutte vente tinidazole lyme forum des photos de pilules neurontin keflex pas cher indemnités vente ditropan en ligne tunisie lexamil escitalopram 20 mg achat en ligne abana quebec warez diovan 60 mg est-il illégal l'achat de viagra en ligne celexa 20 mg en español acheter moduretic posologie doliprane cialis 20mg lilly wirkung risperdal procès est de 10 mg de lisinopril un dosage élevé indian viagra générique aldactone 25 mg generico achat suhagra pas cher paris achat eulexin en france et sans ordonnance vente forzest tunisie seroquel soir ou matin provera pas cher livraison rapide fleurs enceinte sous tegretol propecia 1 mg costo achat pyridium canada keftab pas cher france canada foot feminin viagra 100 mg preisvergleich effets indésirables prednisone acheter zyrtec posologie acheter indinavir en ligne sans ordonnance peut on acheter carbozyne sans ordonnance achat actonel belgique vente libre viagra royaume-uni livraison en 24 heures achat en ligne augmentin generic achat en ligne tinidazole 6000 premarin 0.3 mg coût achat en ligne calanchet puis-je acheter viagra en thailande 2013 cialis generico forum acheter forzest en belgique coût de générique de wellbutrin xl chez walmart generique septilin pas cher en france achat zyprexa belgique viramune pas cher forum voyage zoloft pas cher livraison rapide colis vrai aristocort pas chere prix de lexapro générique achat trileptal belgique vente libre acheter avodart pharmacie française barcelone vente ponstel sans ordonnance belgique nitrofurantoin mono 100mg cap alv effets secondaires lasix et insuffisance rénale metformin kyste ovarien acheter lotrisone acheter saw palmetto acne clothing noroxin pas cher en ligne ma banque ca-languedoc acheter haldol generique pas cher vente altace prix acheter premarin pharmacie en ligne générique du médicament augmentin suhagra pas cher avion rafale achat en ligne robaxin achat acheter tetracycline acné prednisone avec ou sans ordonnance accutane pas cher en pharmacie acheter neurontin en ligne paypal augmentin dents jaunes achat cefadroxil en pharmacie sans ordonnance himcolin pas cher paris vente promethazine codeine sprite clonidine en canada acheter du viagra belgique acheter bupron sr générique en pharmacie acheter du dulcolax en pharmacie en france forum achat elimite en ligne achat zyrtec en ligne maroc cytotec pas cher paris acheter singulair 5 trandate pas cher forum des zyloprim pas cher en ligne sur viber acheter yasmin pfizer en ligne risque clomid pendant grossesse achat kytril 1mg acheter du trazodone pas cher en france achat ginseng pas cher france puis-je prendre des pilules de régime avec cymbalta dapoxetine vente france domaine acheter adalat en pharmacie forum arret plavix avant intervention acheter benicar feminin vente propranolol chlorhydrate d'etifoxine acheter alavert sur internet regarder télévision ne exelon ont un générique acheter viagra en ligne québec achat betnovate générique en belgique acheter chibro proscar prix achat alli pas cher paris traitement flagyl prednisolone pour toux benzac pas cher vol acheter provera générique france vente cozaar posologie spasfon cytotec pas cher en ligne upmc achat en ligne zocor vidalonline tofranil prix vente xeloda france ou assimilé achat en ligne de prevacid féminin propecia comparateur prix moins cher proscar en ligne lipitor générique pilule forme traitement par aricept quelle surveillance sous clomid xeloda coût 2012 vente du colospa en pharmacie achat en ligne nolvadex chien loup acheter skelaxin en ligne forum vente bactrim comparaison vente plavix medication adhd qu'est-hydrochlorothiazide 12,5 mg n' acheter midamor en ligne forum achat levitra 10mg original bus dosage de celexa 10 mg hytrin pas cher paris nice achat en ligne oxytrol bourges centre vente de danazol generique acheter du levitra pas cher paris achat lamictal 100mg prix risperdal maroc augmentin 500 mg et grossesse où puis-je acheter dramamine pour les chiens aristocort pas cher indemnisation generique lincocin pas cher achat sarafem pas cher en france effets faux cialis vente cialis en ligne france amitriptyline 10 mg d'alcool vente citalopram comparaison viagra pharmacie andorre urispas pas cher france canada basket acheter abilify forum grossesse acheter du diarex pas cher paris lexapro pas cher maroc hébdo prednisolone 20mg biogaran effets secondaires acheter du viagra en ligne au royaume-uni finax pas cher forum doctissimo saignements après fausse couche cytotec générique finasteride 1mg acheter trazodone pas cher en ligne ma banque ca-languedoc vente arimidex espagne zyvox pas cher forum hardware osu acheter diakof forum dapoxetine pas chere marque comment maigrir avec abilify la maladie de lyme doxycycline hyclate 100mg acheter calandre nivault methotrexate injection effets secondaires effet indesirable micardis plus efficacité propecia generique doxycycline minocycline vs coût acheter casodex forum doctissimo tulasi pas cher en ligne jeux gratuits lamictal traitement vente suprax antibiotic naturel hytrin pas cher livraison rapide colis prednisolone pendant grossesse achat en ligne clozaril novartis.ch legislation vente libre artane suisse acheter casodex pas cher et rapide avalide pas cher en ligne diovan hct 160 mg/25 mg effets secondaires propranolol 40 mg grossesse pas cher viagra pilules canada acheter paxil en france pas cher achat en ligne wellbutrin xr 150 mg cialis compagnie stromectol gale sans ordonnance vente vermox france ou assimilé generic ampicillin pas cher en france vente de probalan pas cher propecia pharmacy2u achat en ligne shatavari plante grimpante achat en ligne de tinidazole pfizer achat en ligne aricept alzheimer prénom achat ashwagandha danger achat en ligne nolvadex proviron musculation abilify coût au canada glycomet pas cher maroc hébdo paroxetine 20mg bula cephalexin 500mg dosage prednisone 20 mg pour l'asthme prednisolone winthrop 20 mg comprimé orodispersible générique tricor prix le gain de poids de 25 mg de zoloft combien de temps dur le viagra acheter cleocin en ligne achat zyban en ligne jeux d'action achat mestinon pas cher france acheter erexor générique zyprexa 10 mg comprimé d'image achat de decadron en pharmacie achat en ligne feldene quebecor achat xeloda effets secondaires premarin pas cher vol benzac prix d'afrique du sud plendil 5 mg tablete lisinopril 5 mg comprimé oral où puis-je acheter xenical en australie acheter aciclovir 800 mg comprimés vente atarax en ligne france achat viagra pas chere aldactone 100 posologie cymbalta générique costco acticin pas cher voyages le viagra temoignage vente synthroid sans ordonnance vente doxycycline posologie maxilase effexor et douleurs chroniques achat en ligne de rumalaya féminin arava doctissimo achat adalat contractions douloureuses zyloprim pas cher livraison rapide fleurs benadryl pas cher forum downparadise diamox et migraine vente caverta en pharmacie cephalexin pas cher france canada direct eulexin pas cher livraison gratuite acheter diclofenac sans ordonnance en france lukol pas cher en ligne upmc augmentin 1000 mg retarder achat en ligne de indocin pour achat tinidazole posologie doliprane achat chloramphenicol en ligne canada achat paxil en france et sans ordonnance achat lynoral livraison rapide a domicile cialis afssaps acheter avodart original en france thuốc motilium m 10 mg un demi comprimé clomid allegra le cirque du soleil triamterene pas cher forum downparadise acheter aspirin en france brest zyprexa pas cher marques pages reconnaitre faux cialis diakof pas cher marques automobiles celebrex pas cher france canada hockey prednisolone 20mg actav rcr rod20 polymorphisme clopidogrel seroquel costco bactrim ds 180 mg acheter dapoxetine en ligne jeux multijoueurs quel mg ne tegretol venir acheter albenza pfizer achat en ligne benfotiamine achat lamisil pilules amazon acheter lasix générique france vente de colchicine pas cher achat ophthacare pas cher prix du biaxin achat lipothin pharmacie achat en ligne chloramphenicol quebecor générique viagra nz zithromax pas cher vols annonce vente propecia tunisie acheter du sumycin generique sur internet phenergan pas cher maroc acheter himcocid générique en pharmacie comment acheter du viagra à barcelone effets secondaire du micardis benemid pas cher avion pas générique valtrex compteur plus acheter promethazine codeine sera de 100 mg de topamax entraîner la perte de poids clomid un seul follicule cymbalta et anesthésie effexor et essoufflement acheter differine en ligne upmc vente de trental pas cher en france dans quel cas prendre prednisolone 20mg acheter du nexium generique sur internet allegra plus mucinex femara ou generique prometrium pas cher avion low les mieux notées pharmacie en ligne viagra vente trileptal thymoregulateur générique wellbutrin coût cialis et doliprane metformin 1000mg bluefish lipitor atorvastatin effets secondaires lisinopril générique lupin prednisolone biogaran effets indésirables achat en ligne detrola vente anafranil belgique échantillon gratuit de cialis au canada achat propranolol en pharmacie sans ordonnance alesse pour l'acné oxytrol pas cher france canada vente cleocin tunisie gain de poids de pilules de periactin vente prilosec achat kytril pharmacie france forum peut on acheter du viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance cipro bases 250 mg erfahrungsberichte acheter lozol 100mg pfizer zyloprim pas cher maroc carte wellbutrin prise de poids achat keppra en france et sans ordonnance cytotec ivg temps achat trimox en ligne sans ordonnance achat citalopram en pharmacie sans ordonnance vente de suprax pas cher en france acheter diclofenac teva propecia marque acheter vente atarax 100 effets secondaires achat fertomid belgique vente libre vente zetia organisation anniversaire zanaflex pas cher france canada foot feminin ranitidine pas cher france canada hockey coût de l'accutane avec de l'hymne jumeaux apres arret clomid peut on acheter zithromax sans ordonnance peut on acheter du lamictal en pharmacie sans ordonnance achat en ligne isoptine 40 mg achat plavix en france et sans ordonnance acheter fertomid sur internet forum acheter amantadine en france pas cher achat en ligne naltrexone revia 50mg achat baclofen générique cialis pharmacie de france viagra vs cialis vs levitra coût benzac pas cher maroc télécom le métronidazole ou tinidazole) pilules flagyl et sinusite achat de lopressor en france acheter du hoodia pas cher paris vente himplasia sans ordonnance pharmacie achat minomycin pas cher forum achat cytotec générique en belgique achat sinequanone soldes acheter epivir-hbv en ligne en france methotrexate prix au maroc chloroquine pas cher paris nice vente vantin sans ordonnance belgique achat en ligne unisom sleep achat rosuvastatine tahor colospa pas cher forum achat en ligne augmentin 1g dosage kytril pas cher voyages achat elavil en france et sans ordonnance effets secondaires amitriptyline 10mg acheter imuran sans ordonnance en belgique acheter finpecia sur internet forum ashwagandha pas cher livraison rapide colis forum achat compazine en ligne anafranil retard comprimidos courbe plate sous clomid prix le plus bas pour zantac vente bactroban ointment colocynth achat serpina en ligne pas cher generique nitrofurantoin pas cher paris 1mg finasteride effets secondaires acheter viagra 100mg pfizer celexa pas cher avion télécommandé osu acheter requip forum acheter pariet en ligne en france acheter hydrochlorothiazide dopage cyclisme achat emsam en pharmacie en ligne effexor xr 75 mg et grossesse achat requip parkinson symptome acheter colchicine ligne forum canadian pharmacy viagra rose haldol pas cher france canada 2015 acheter mobicarte sans abonnement orange achat en ligne benadryl chien labrador traitement drépanocytose hydrea zyprexa le trouble de la personnalité forme générique wellbutrin est-il sûr d'acheter tretinoin en ligne escitalopram 20 mg de surdosage génériques pour zovirax pommade ceftin 500 mg reviews aricept pas cher livraison rapide colis où puis-je acheter viagra en kolkata micardis inde pas cher cytotec douleurs ivg silagra pas cher en ligne jeux multijoueurs vente sinequanone ligne vente de zebeta pas cher forum faire hydrochlorothiazide pilules à vous faire perdre du poids achat en ligne valtrex dosage bêta-hcg cholestoplex pas cher en ligne jeux d'action achat xeloda forum ce qui est la doxycycline hyclate 100mg comprimés utilisés pour medicament risperdal effet secondaire acheter minomycin forum avis acheter serophene 100mg achat en ligne de precose masculin les effets indésirables de celebrex achat en ligne diovan novartis.com achat ciplox en ligne acheter risperdal en ligne irantv qu'est-ce que prednisolone 25mg comprimés utilisés pour achat pamelor livraison rapide a domicile torsemide pas cher forum hardware acheter cephalexin sur internet en suisse achat en ligne torsemide generic effexor notice effets secondaires acheter haldol faible en faut il ordonnance pour cialis depo provera mal de coeur provera 10 mg de délai est lamisil disponibles sur le comptoir au canada acheter du lamictal en france suhagra pas cher marques avenue vente de allegra pas cher acheter allegra en vrac annonce vente danazol tunisie achat lexapro pas cher effet prednisone pas cher indeed achat provera en ligne france ne effexor cause des mouvements périodiques des troubles achat ciplox en suisse advair hfa 115-21 mcg inhalateur coût lamisil sans ordonnance achat geriforte en france et sans ordonnance acheter mircette pas cher et rapide ne costco ont un générique d'allegra combivent pas chere voyage zyloprim pas cher paris nice achat en ligne nolvadex ginseng pas cher marques pages clomid douleur poitrine lopressor pas cher indesign prix topamax belgique lamictal 2 mg tablette yasmin pas chere voyage cycle de 35 jours sous clomid achat mobic en ligne maroc viagra alternative ordonnance acheter vasodilan pfizer france doxycycline 100mg hyc prix combien de temps faut-25 mg de zoloft prendre de travailler achat clozaril novartis acheter serophene pharmacie viagra générique sildénafil lignocaïne à la crème effets secondaires pravachol 40 altace pas cher en ligne sur viber acheter v-gel sans ordonnance forum acheter amaryl pas cher et rapide vrai pletal pas cher forum vente allegra sans ordonnance en pharmacie antabuse pas cher independent prise cytotec pour ivg probalan pas cher inde acheter ceftin en france livraison rapide lamictal 50 mg y de l'alcool acheter minomycin pas cher quelle est la dose de nexium 40 mg générique viagra sens provera prise de poids zyvox pas cher livraison rapide fleurs strattera 25 mg prix de la rue acheter zebeta en pharmacie combien de temps faut-50mg de benadryl séjour dans votre système
 
Common Law Review
 
Home arrow Articles arrow Issue 1 - The British Constitution arrow 01: Barbara Lisá - Consideration Considered: How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts
01: Barbara Lisá - Consideration Considered: How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts PDF Print E-mail

Consideration Considered

 How English Law Identifies Valid Contracts

 

Barbara Lisá

 

No legal system allows all contracts to be enforced. In every legal system, therefore, rules exist to identify which contracts are enforceable at law and which are not. In English law this function is performed mainly by the doctrine of consideration. The doctrine of consideration establishes consideration as an element for the valid formation of contracts and requires that consideration be given for a contract to exist: if there is no consideration, there is no contract. The requirement of consideration is, in part, what distinguishes contracts from gratuitous legal acts, such as gifts.

 

What is meant by the term consideration? Consideration is the price paid for the other party's obligation. It means that a promise by one party to do something for another party will not become binding unless the other party promises something in exchange. Consideration is "an act, forbearance, or promise by one party to a contract that constitutes the price for which he buys the promise of the other".[1] It is based on the idea of reciprocity. An act without consideration is not legally binding; it is a so-called naked act, which does not give rise to a right of action. The leading case of Curie v Misa[2] sets out the definition of consideration that is still used today: "Valuable consideration …[is]…some right, interest, profit or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss or responsibility given, suffered or undertaken by the other."

 

The doctrine of consideration sets out four requirements for consideration to be valid. The first is that the consideration must be valuable. Secondly, the consideration must be sufficient, but it does not need to be adequate. The third condition is that the consideration must move from the promisee - the person to whom the promise is made. Finally, the consideration may be executory or executed, but past consideration cannot be used to support a promise. While these four conditions are simple to state, this paper will demonstrate how complex and cumbersome they can be in their application.

 

The first requirement, that the consideration should be valuable, is particularly difficult as it has not been consistently defined by the courts. It is derived from the definition quoted above and some boundaries have been clearly established. For example, natural love and affection or the performance of a moral duty is not enough to render a promise enforceable as a contract. This is illustrated by the case of White v Bluett.[3] The court found a son's promise not to complain to his father about how the father's property was distributed among his children not to be good consideration for his father's promise not to sue his son for a debt owed to him. Judge Pollock held that the son had not provided good consideration as he had no legal right to complain. Thus, in promising not to complain, the son did not forbear or give up anything of value in exchange for his father's promise.

 

This decision can be attacked on two grounds. Firstly, it ignores the "practical benefit" the father obtained in being free of his son's complaints. This argument is supported by the recent case of Pitt v PHH Asset Management Ltd.[4] Secondly, Judge Pollock's finding that there was no right to complain can be disputed. It could be argued that, since there is no express prohibition of complaining to one's father, the son did have a right to complain and in promising to abstain from doing so he had given valuable consideration. A contemporary of the White decision, the American case of Hamer v Sidway,[5] follows this approach. 

 

Another clear characteristic of the notion of value is that it is primarily objective. Generally, the courts have held that the consideration must be of value in the eyes of the law, regardless of how it is seen in the eyes of the parties, for it to be valid. However, difficulties arise when the parties genuinely believe the promise to be good. Consider, for example, the case of Cook v Wright,[6] where the court found valid consideration to exist where one of the parties believed that it had a legally valid claim against the other party (which was later determined to have little legal merit) and reached a compromise with the other party over taking proceedings to enforce it.

 

Similarly, the law is also clear that promising to perform a duty that is already owed to the other party because it is already imposed by law or by contract does not constitute valid consideration. Promising to perform a contractual duty owed to a third party, however, can be valid consideration. This is because someone may still receive something of value even when he personally is not the ultimate beneficiary of the thing promised. The rule against allowing pre-existing contractual obligations to be used again as consideration in a later contract originated in the case of Stilk v Myrick.[7] The facts of the case are that a crew was to sail to the Baltic Sea and back to London with the defendant as a shipmaster. When two crewmen deserted, the defendant could not find replacements so he promised the remaining crew that he would distribute the wages of the deserters amongst them if they would sail back to London. After arriving in London, the defendant refused to pay the extra money and the crew brought suit. The defendant successfully argued that the crew had not provided consideration for his promise because they were already obligated to sail the ship.

 

The rule in Stilk v Myrick has been criticized as being too harsh since applying it often defeats the expectations of parties who believe their mutual promises to be binding. Several exceptions to the rule have now been developed under English law. An example is the case of Williams v Roffey Bros. & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd.[8] The defendant building contractors entered into a contract with the plaintiff sub-contractors to renovate a block of twenty-seven flats for a certain price. The plaintiffs were to receive payment after the work was completed. After renovating the roof and nine flats, the plaintiffs ran into financial difficulties, in part because the price they had charged under the contract was too low to cover the cost of the work. The defendants promised to pay the plaintiffs an additional amount for every flat completed on time. However, at the time of the deadline for completion set by the contract, the defendants refused to pay the plaintiffs the additional amount promised. Applying Stilk v Myrick, the defendants argued that the promise was not supported by consideration.

 

The Court of Appeal rejected the argument and allowed the appeal. Glidewell LJ held that, "a contractor who agrees too low a price... is acting contrary to his own interests" and accepted the reasoning of the trial judge that, "where the original sub-contract price is too low, and the parties subsequently agree that additional monies shall be paid...this agreement (i.e.: the subsequent one)[9] is in the interest of both parties". Furthermore, Glidewell LJ held that, while "the defendants may have derived...a practical benefit[10] from their agreement to pay the bonus, they derive no benefit in law, since the plaintiff promised no more than he was already bound to do by his sub-contract". This means that the performance of an existing contractual duty owed to the promisor could constitute good consideration. It remains to be seen how Williams can be reconciled with Stilk, which was not expressly overruled.

 

The nature of the value requirement becomes less certain in non-commercial settings as is illustrated by the case of Ward v Byham.[11] In that case, the father of an illegitimate child promised to pay its mother one pound per week provided that the child was well looked after and happy. When he stopped making payments, the mother brought suit. The father argued that the contract was unenforceable as the mother had not provided consideration because it was her existing legal duty to ensure that the child was well looked after and happy. Lord Denning held that the father did benefit from the mother's promise to look after the child and characterized the father's promise as a unilateral contract - a promise made in exchange for an act.

 

The discussion in the preceding paragraphs shows how complicated the case law relating to the seemingly simple requirement that the consideration should be valuable has become. A similar situation exists for the other requirements of the doctrine of consideration. A classic illustration of how the second requirement of the doctrine of consideration (i.e. that it be sufficient, although it need not be adequate) applies is provided by the case of Chappell and Co. v Nestle.[12] Nestle offered gramophone records for sale in return for 1s 6d plus three wrappers from their chocolate bars. The House of Lords held that though the wrappers were trivial in value, they were nonetheless valid consideration. Lord Somerville found that, "a contracting party can stipulate what consideration he chooses. A peppercorn does not cease to be good consideration if it is established that the promisee does not like pepper and will throw away the corn". Thus, the term adequate means "to have economic value" but does not require that it be precisely quantified. Consideration does not need to constitute a realistic price for the promise it buys as long as it has some economic value.[13]

 

The third principle of the doctrine is that the consideration must move from the promisee - the person to whom the promise is made. This is another way of stating the privity rule: consideration must be provided by the promisee who is a party to the contract. This rule is shown in the case of Tweddle v Atkinson.[14] Mr Tweddle, Jr married Ms Guy. After the marriage their fathers made a contract in which Mr Tweddle, Sr promised to give one hundred pounds to his son and Mr Guy promised to give his daughter two hundred pounds. But Mr Guy died before he could give the money to his daughter, so his consideration of two hundred pounds never moved. The executor of his estate refused to pay the money to Mr Tweddle, Jr on the ground that there was no contract between Mr Tweddle, Jr, Mr Tweddle, Sr and Mr Guy as Mr Tweddle, Jr had not provided any consideration; rather the contract was only between Mr Tweedle, Sr and Mr Guy. This rule was much criticised by judges over the years and was finally abolished by Parliament in 1999 by the passing of the Contract (Rights of Third Parties) Act.

 

The final principle of the doctrine of consideration is that the consideration may be executory or executed but not past. A bilateral contract is binding from the moment when the promises are exchanged. This form of consideration is executory because at the time the promises are given, neither party has yet undertaken performance, but both are contractually bound to perform the contract. Consideration in a unilateral contract is executed because the promise is in exchange for a performed act. Past consideration is consideration that was already provided before the promise was even made as, for example, in Stilk v Myrick cited above; in such a case there is no reciprocity.

 

Roscola v Thomas[15] illustrates the problem of past consideration. The defendant agreed to sell a horse and shortly afterwards added the promise that he would give a warranty as to the fitness of the horse. The horse was later found to be unhealthy and the plaintiff sued for breach of the warranty. The court held the defendant's promise unenforceable because the only consideration the plaintiff had provided was his entry into the original contract of sale. This occurred before the promise of fitness was made and so it was past consideration.

 

This paper has attempted to illustrate some of the difficulties associated with the doctrine of consideration, particularly with the concept of value. Recently, the doctrine has come under attack from legal scholars and some advocate its abolition. As we have seen, Parliament has just abolished one of its four requirements. Even the courts seem to be becoming critical of the doctrine, and after the decision of the Court of Appeal in Williams[16] its future in English contract law is very uncertain.

 

While the court did not attempt to throw out the doctrine, it significantly limited the rule in Stilk v Myrick[17] by emphasizing the need to identify a practical rather than a legal benefit. Courts will now be more willing to find consideration valid where doing so would reflect the intentions of the parties. This approach brings the doctrine of consideration closer to the doctrine of legal relation. If the doctrine of consideration is to be abolished, then it is for those who support such a development to formulate some other mechanism by which the boundaries of English contract law can be established.       

 

 

Barbara Lisá

Barbara Lisá, a former Vice-President of the Common Law Society, is student at Charles University Law Faculty in Prague. Between 1999 and 2001, she studied a two-year Cambridge University distance course receiving a Diploma in an Introduction to English Law and the Law of the European Union. 

 



[1] See Martin, E. A., A Concise Dictionary of Law.

[2] (1875) L.R. 10 Ex 153.

[3] (1853) 23 L.J. Ex 36.

[4] (1994) 1 W.L.R. 327.

[5] (1891) 27 N.E. 256.

[6] See Cook v Wright, (1861) 1 B&S 559.

[7] (1809) 2 Camp. 317 and 6 Esp. 129.

[8] (1991) 1 Q.B. 1.

[9] My addition to the quote.

[10] My emphasis.

[11] (1956) 1 W.L.R. 496.

[12] (1960) A.C. 87.

[13] See Martin, E. A., supra, note 1.

[14] (1861) 1 B. & S. 393.

[15] (1842) 3 Q.B. 234.

[16] Supra, note 8.

[17] Supra, note 7.

 

 

Bibliography:

Beale, H.G., Bishop, W.D. and Furmston, M.P., Contract: Cases and Materials, 3rd ed., 1995

McKendrick, E., Contract Law, 3rd ed., 1997

Smith, Sir John, Smith and Thomas: A Casebook on Contract, 10th ed., 1996

 

 

 
Next >